Fantastic work in collecting your extensive research and making is easily accessible! I'm currently working on a post, "A Guide to the future, in alphabetical order", and will definitely be sharing your great new resource collection with readers. Thanks again for your years of dedicated work!
Dr Haidt: I see that AI companies have invited theologians to advise them on the morality of their LLMs. But have they invited you or anyone you know who is an expert on the science of morality to advise them?
We just published a list of "Tricky Twenty" apps parents should monitor and link to several of your articles. Thank you for helping educate parents! https://livingroomapp.com/tricky-twenty
Endlessly thankful for your work, Jon and Zach. As I've said many times, when many are throttling down in life, you're busier than ever with things that truly matter.
Parents at my school ask me about screen time almost every week, and most of what they've read is somebody's opinion. We just did a podcast on it that's coming out this week. Having one place to send them for the actual research helps. I'll be sharing the site with our families and the business clients I work with who have kids at home.
Thank you Zach and Jonathan; while operating my full-time solo private psychotherapy practice, I have been working on a literature review project, compiling information from published research, on the effects of immersion, or 'willful suspension of disbelief' for extended periods of time, on perception, beliefs, behaviors and relationships. Please let me know if there are any opportunities where I may be of service for your lab. Thank you very much. Kelly Kilcoyne LMFT
Thank you very much for recognizing and responding to my comment.
This is a lengthy comment, I hope you have a few moments to read, reflect and respond to it. Feel free to contact me directly if you would like to discuss this information further, my contact info is accessible on my website: https://kellykilcoyne.com/contact/
I hope you're doing well, and that you have a very pleasant day.
I'm curious if you ever heard of, or personally met, BJ Fogg of the Stanford Persuasive Technology Lab, now rebranded as Stanford Behavior Design Lab? Or the term 'Captology' or the research of BJ Fogg at the Stanford Behavior Design Lab?
I imagine that you probably have, though if not, here is a primer:
Captology is the study of computers as persuasive technologies. This area of inquiry explores the overlapping space between persuasion in general, with emphasis on influence, motivation, behavior change, and computing technology. This includes the design, research, and program analysis of interactive computing products, such as the Web, desktop software, specialized devices, etc., created for the purpose of changing people's attitudes or behaviors.
B. J. Fogg in 1996 derived the term captology from an acronym: Computers As Persuasive Technologies. In 2003, he published the first book on captology, entitled "Persuasive Technology: Using Computers to Change What We Think and Do."
Fogg claims that Captology is not the same thing as Behavior Design, however, I firmly believe it provides lubrication for intentional, as well as unintentional, behavior changes, and in the span of human evolution, is a relatively recent modern addition to formulaic engineering of changes in human behavior, as were the initial intentions of the corpus of BJ Fogg's research.
In 2007, around the same time as the advent of the iPhone and android smartphone, Fogg and the Stanford Persuasive Technology Lab published a second textbook, "Mobile Persuasion: 20 Perspectives on the Future of Behavior Change." This book is edited by B.J. Fogg and Dean Eckles, published by Stanford Captology Media, and explores the core concept of how mobile phones and portable devices function as personal, real-time channels for human behavior change and persuasion. Fogg emphasizes that mobile persuasion leverages "kairos," the ancient Greek concept of the right or opportune timing for influence, because mobile devices accompany users throughout their daily routines—at the gym, grocery store, or work—rather than locking them to a static desktop screen.
Key Themes & Ideas in the book Mobile Persuasion
Hot Triggers: Fogg and related Captology research highlight "hot triggers"—calls to action delivered in the exact moment a user is able to act on them immediately.
Spontaneous Influence: Unlike billboards or desktop computers, mobile devices bridge physical and digital contexts, making digital persuasion immediate and contextual.
Contributing Authors: The 166-page text compiles essays and insights from 20 industry and academic perspectives, including:
• Ian Bogost
• Sunny Consolvo
• Martin Cooper
• Dean Eckles (co-editor)
• B.J. Fogg (editor)
• Eric Paulos
• Numerous other designers, researchers, and technologists.
Also worth noting, and considering, is the Fogg Behavior Model (B = MAP) or how these mobile principles evolved into modern app design and engineering habit formation, often without the device user's consent and/or conscious awareness.
The B = MAP model is the Fogg Behavior Model, created by Dr. BJ Fogg, founder of the Behavior Design Lab at Stanford University.
It states that a specific Behavior (B) happens only when Motivation (M), Ability (A), and a Prompt (P) converge at the exact same moment. If any of these three elements is missing, the behavior will not occur.
The Three Core Elements of the Fogg Behavior Model:
• Motivation (M): Your desire or willingness to do the behavior right now. It is driven by three core dimensions:
• Sensation: Pleasure or pain.
• Anticipation: Hope or fear.
• Belonging: Social acceptance or rejection.
• Ability (A): How easy or simple it is for you to perform the behavior. Fogg measures ability by reducing six limiting factors:
• Time
• Money
• Physical effort
• Brain cycles (mental effort)
• Social deviance (going against social norms)
• Non-routine (how much it disrupts your normal schedule)
• Prompt (P): The trigger or call-to-action that tells you to act now. Without a prompt, nothing happens. Prompts come in three types:
• Spark: Used when high ability is present, but low motivation (e.g., an inspiring message or re-engagement email).
• Facilitator: Used when high motivation is present, but low ability (e.g., a one-click button that removes friction).
• Signal: Used when high ability and high motivation are both present (e.g., a simple reminder or calendar chime).
How They Work Together
• The Trade-Off: Motivation and ability have a compensatory relationship. If a task is very easy (high ability), you don't need much motivation to do it. If a task is hard (low ability), you need a massive amount of motivation.
• The Action Line: In Fogg’s visual model, a curved line separates when a behavior happens from when it fails. If the combination of your current motivation and ability sits above the action line and a prompt fires, you perform the behavior.
• Application: The model is widely used in UX design, product management, and building personal "Tiny Habits."
But NYU and its digital learning lab were responsible for pumping so much tech INTO schools in the first place! I experienced this first hand as a parent of a public school child. NYU trained teachers in tech and pushed digital learning platforms in schools. Why should we trust anything affiliated with NYU to remedy this situation?
This is going to be a great resource, thank you! How is this funded and how do you ensure tech companies don't play a role in funding or directing research, even in a tiny way?
Thank you all for your tireless work in this space! We, the parents, are grateful!
Fantastic work in collecting your extensive research and making is easily accessible! I'm currently working on a post, "A Guide to the future, in alphabetical order", and will definitely be sharing your great new resource collection with readers. Thanks again for your years of dedicated work!
Dr Haidt: I see that AI companies have invited theologians to advise them on the morality of their LLMs. But have they invited you or anyone you know who is an expert on the science of morality to advise them?
yes, i gave a zoom lecture at OpenAI in 2023, on moral psychology. No idea if it helped them or they remembered it.
Your work inspires and informs mine. Thank you!
We just published a list of "Tricky Twenty" apps parents should monitor and link to several of your articles. Thank you for helping educate parents! https://livingroomapp.com/tricky-twenty
Endlessly thankful for your work, Jon and Zach. As I've said many times, when many are throttling down in life, you're busier than ever with things that truly matter.
Thank you for your tireless work on behalf of our children.
I second Emily! We will never be able to thank you enough 💗
Parents at my school ask me about screen time almost every week, and most of what they've read is somebody's opinion. We just did a podcast on it that's coming out this week. Having one place to send them for the actual research helps. I'll be sharing the site with our families and the business clients I work with who have kids at home.
Thank you for doing this work!!
Thank you Zach and Jonathan; while operating my full-time solo private psychotherapy practice, I have been working on a literature review project, compiling information from published research, on the effects of immersion, or 'willful suspension of disbelief' for extended periods of time, on perception, beliefs, behaviors and relationships. Please let me know if there are any opportunities where I may be of service for your lab. Thank you very much. Kelly Kilcoyne LMFT
Dr. Haidt,
Thank you very much for recognizing and responding to my comment.
This is a lengthy comment, I hope you have a few moments to read, reflect and respond to it. Feel free to contact me directly if you would like to discuss this information further, my contact info is accessible on my website: https://kellykilcoyne.com/contact/
I hope you're doing well, and that you have a very pleasant day.
I'm curious if you ever heard of, or personally met, BJ Fogg of the Stanford Persuasive Technology Lab, now rebranded as Stanford Behavior Design Lab? Or the term 'Captology' or the research of BJ Fogg at the Stanford Behavior Design Lab?
I imagine that you probably have, though if not, here is a primer:
Captology is the study of computers as persuasive technologies. This area of inquiry explores the overlapping space between persuasion in general, with emphasis on influence, motivation, behavior change, and computing technology. This includes the design, research, and program analysis of interactive computing products, such as the Web, desktop software, specialized devices, etc., created for the purpose of changing people's attitudes or behaviors.
B. J. Fogg in 1996 derived the term captology from an acronym: Computers As Persuasive Technologies. In 2003, he published the first book on captology, entitled "Persuasive Technology: Using Computers to Change What We Think and Do."
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://memoof.me/download/922/pdf/922.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjp64ruhfuXAxUoEEQIHV3sOTsQFnoECB4QAQ&sqi=2&usg=AOvVaw3qGy-rTznFdc8Oob1yDF0q
https://archive.org/details/persuasivetechno0000fogg
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persuasive_technology?wprov=sfla1
Fogg claims that Captology is not the same thing as Behavior Design, however, I firmly believe it provides lubrication for intentional, as well as unintentional, behavior changes, and in the span of human evolution, is a relatively recent modern addition to formulaic engineering of changes in human behavior, as were the initial intentions of the corpus of BJ Fogg's research.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B._J._Fogg?wprov=sfla1
Here is a link to Fogg's thesis: "Charismatic Computers" https://dl.acm.org/doi/book/10.5555/287026
In 2007, around the same time as the advent of the iPhone and android smartphone, Fogg and the Stanford Persuasive Technology Lab published a second textbook, "Mobile Persuasion: 20 Perspectives on the Future of Behavior Change." This book is edited by B.J. Fogg and Dean Eckles, published by Stanford Captology Media, and explores the core concept of how mobile phones and portable devices function as personal, real-time channels for human behavior change and persuasion. Fogg emphasizes that mobile persuasion leverages "kairos," the ancient Greek concept of the right or opportune timing for influence, because mobile devices accompany users throughout their daily routines—at the gym, grocery store, or work—rather than locking them to a static desktop screen.
Key Themes & Ideas in the book Mobile Persuasion
Hot Triggers: Fogg and related Captology research highlight "hot triggers"—calls to action delivered in the exact moment a user is able to act on them immediately.
Spontaneous Influence: Unlike billboards or desktop computers, mobile devices bridge physical and digital contexts, making digital persuasion immediate and contextual.
Contributing Authors: The 166-page text compiles essays and insights from 20 industry and academic perspectives, including:
• Ian Bogost
• Sunny Consolvo
• Martin Cooper
• Dean Eckles (co-editor)
• B.J. Fogg (editor)
• Eric Paulos
• Numerous other designers, researchers, and technologists.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1452837.Mobile_Persuasion
Also worth noting, and considering, is the Fogg Behavior Model (B = MAP) or how these mobile principles evolved into modern app design and engineering habit formation, often without the device user's consent and/or conscious awareness.
The B = MAP model is the Fogg Behavior Model, created by Dr. BJ Fogg, founder of the Behavior Design Lab at Stanford University.
It states that a specific Behavior (B) happens only when Motivation (M), Ability (A), and a Prompt (P) converge at the exact same moment. If any of these three elements is missing, the behavior will not occur.
The Three Core Elements of the Fogg Behavior Model:
• Motivation (M): Your desire or willingness to do the behavior right now. It is driven by three core dimensions:
• Sensation: Pleasure or pain.
• Anticipation: Hope or fear.
• Belonging: Social acceptance or rejection.
• Ability (A): How easy or simple it is for you to perform the behavior. Fogg measures ability by reducing six limiting factors:
• Time
• Money
• Physical effort
• Brain cycles (mental effort)
• Social deviance (going against social norms)
• Non-routine (how much it disrupts your normal schedule)
• Prompt (P): The trigger or call-to-action that tells you to act now. Without a prompt, nothing happens. Prompts come in three types:
• Spark: Used when high ability is present, but low motivation (e.g., an inspiring message or re-engagement email).
• Facilitator: Used when high motivation is present, but low ability (e.g., a one-click button that removes friction).
• Signal: Used when high ability and high motivation are both present (e.g., a simple reminder or calendar chime).
How They Work Together
• The Trade-Off: Motivation and ability have a compensatory relationship. If a task is very easy (high ability), you don't need much motivation to do it. If a task is hard (low ability), you need a massive amount of motivation.
• The Action Line: In Fogg’s visual model, a curved line separates when a behavior happens from when it fails. If the combination of your current motivation and ability sits above the action line and a prompt fires, you perform the behavior.
• Application: The model is widely used in UX design, product management, and building personal "Tiny Habits."
But NYU and its digital learning lab were responsible for pumping so much tech INTO schools in the first place! I experienced this first hand as a parent of a public school child. NYU trained teachers in tech and pushed digital learning platforms in schools. Why should we trust anything affiliated with NYU to remedy this situation?
Take a moment to have a look at this new development: https://ctaus.substack.com/p/restoring-the-healing-ethos-of-therapy?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=4l6g8j
Should we have hopes that the upcoming DSM will address any of these matters in formal diagnoses?
I am very impressed with the mobilization of excellent individuals and resources. Who is funding this amazing and important work? It cannot be cheap.
This is going to be a great resource, thank you! How is this funded and how do you ensure tech companies don't play a role in funding or directing research, even in a tiny way?